
Discourse Before the Succession
The Union Breaks in Two
The winter sun sat low in the sky, casting a soft gold over the bustling Saturday farmers market. Stalls overflowed with sweet potatoes, cornmeal, jars of sorghum syrup, and bolts of cotton cloth. Women in bonnets and shawls huddled together, whispering the latest news.
Clara Whitfield walked between the stalls, her basket hooked tightly over her arm. She was thirty, sharp-eyed, and known for having opinions she rarely voiced. Today, though, silence felt like a stone on her chest.
Behind her, two of her friends caught up—Lydia Parker and Martha Reeves, cheeks flushed with excitement.
“Clara!” Lydia called, breathless. “Have you heard? It’s done. They voted at the convention this morning. Mississippi has seceded!”
Martha clasped her gloved hands together. “Finally! We’re standing up for ourselves. No more Northern meddling.”
Clara’s stomach tightened. She looked from one beaming face to the other.
“I heard,” she said softly. “Everyone in town has heard.”
Lydia leaned closer. “I thought you’d be thrilled. This is our moment. Our men will defend our rights, our way of life.”
Clara picked up an apple from a nearby crate, turning it in her palm. She wished the red on its skin didn’t look so much like spilled ink on the newspapers announcing WAR IS NEAR.
“Martha,” she said gently, “Lydia… do you truly believe war will protect us? Our sons, our brothers—they’ll be the ones fighting.”
Martha scoffed, waving a dismissive hand. “If we show strength, the North will back down. It’ll be over in weeks.”
Clara lowered her voice. “And if they don’t? What then? What of the people caught in the middle? The enslaved, the poor farmers, the townsfolk with nothing to gain from this?”
Lydia’s smile faltered. “Clara, you sound like those Unionists. People will talk.”
“Let them,” Clara said, her chin lifting a notch. “I love Mississippi. I was born here. I want her to prosper. But I fear we are walking into fire… and cheering the sparks.”
The market around them roared with chatter—someone shouted the news again, loud enough for the whole street:
“Mississippi’s out! We’re a sovereign state now!”
A cheer rose like a wave.
Clara watched the excitement ripple through the crowd, the way people embraced, the way pride glowed brighter than the winter sun.
Martha looked at her with mild pity. “Sometimes, Clara, a woman must trust that the men know what’s best.”
Clara shook her head. “And sometimes,” she replied quietly, “a woman must see the danger before anyone else will admit it.”
For a moment, the three stood silently as a gust of cold wind swept through the market, rattling crates and fluttering skirt hems.
Lydia broke the tension, looping her arm through Clara’s. “Come on,” she said warmly. “Let’s buy our supper and talk no more of gloomy things. Tonight is a celebration.”
Clara allowed herself to be pulled along, though her steps felt heavy.
As they walked, she whispered to herself, barely audible over the noise of the celebrating crowd:
“I pray Mississippi survives the pride of today.”
And in her heart, she knew this day would change everything—her friendships, her community, and her beloved state—whether anyone else at the market realized it yet or not.
Clara, Lydia, and Martha continued weaving through the stalls, but Clara’s mind was miles away. The air smelled of woodsmoke and roasting pecans, but beneath it there was something sour—fear, unrest, uncertainty.
A merchant selling ribbons waved at them. “Ladies! Secession special—confederate colors for half price!” He proudly held up red, white, and blue rosettes.
Martha clapped her hands. “Oh, lovely!”
Clara frowned. “The Confederacy isn’t even formed yet. We’re buying symbols of something that doesn’t exist.”
“It will,” Martha said confidently. “You’ll see.”
Clara paid for her vegetables and stepped aside, letting her friends chatter at the ribbon stand.
She drifted toward the edge of the market where an older man, Mr. Harris, was arranging turnips. He had known Clara since she was a child and always spoke his mind.
“Morning, Miss Clara,” he said, not looking up. “Quite a noise people making today.”
She exhaled. “They’re celebrating something they barely understand.”
“Mm,” he grunted. “My boy’s fourteen. Too young for fighting, too old to ignore it. I don’t much care for that math.”
Clara’s heart tugged. “I wish others felt as you do.”
“Most folks don’t think ahead,” he said, wiping his hands on his apron. “They just follow whoever shouts the loudest.”
Before Clara could answer, Lydia and Martha rejoined her, ribbons pinned proudly to their shawls.
“Clara, you should get one!” Lydia insisted. “It’s history!”
Clara forced a smile. “I don’t need a ribbon to know history is happening.”
Martha rolled her eyes. “You sound just like those Northern newspapers.”
“I sound like someone who doesn’t want war,” Clara replied firmly.
Lydia’s expression softened. “Clara… please don’t let this divide us.”
Clara looked at her friends—women she had grown up with, laughed with, mourned with. She hated the wedge forming between them, sharp as a knife’s edge.
“It won’t,” Clara said at last. “But I can’t pretend to be joyful over something that fills me with dread.”
They walked together again, this time more quietly. In the distance, bells began ringing from the courthouse tower, celebrating the vote.
Martha cheered. Lydia clapped her hands.
Clara stared at the courthouse, feeling something cold settle in her bones.
She whispered, “Those bells sound less like celebration… and more like warning.”
Historical Synopsis
On January 9, 1861, Mississippi became the second state to secede from the United States, following South Carolina’s withdrawal in December 1860. The decision emerged during a rapidly escalating national crisis over the expansion of slavery, states’ rights, and political power following Abraham Lincoln’s election in November 1860. Mississippi’s secession convention met in Jackson and voted 84 to 15 in favor of secession.
Mississippi’s leaders issued a formal Declaration of Causes, explicitly stating that their departure from the Union was primarily motivated by the defense of slavery, which they described as “the greatest material interest of the world.” The declaration accused the federal government and Northern states of hostility toward the institution of slavery and of threatening the economic and social structure of the state.
Mississippi’s action helped accelerate the collapse of the Union—four more Deep South states seceded shortly after. By February 1861, these states formed the Confederate States of America, setting the stage for the outbreak of the American Civil War in April.
This story is based on documented historical records and contemporaneous accounts
Works Cited
Mississippi. A Declaration of the Immediate Causes which Induce and Justify the Secession of the State of Mississippi from the Federal Union. Jackson, MS, 1861.
Lincoln, Abraham. Annual Message to Congress. 3 Dec. 1860. National Archives, https://www.archives.gov.
Current, Richard N. Lincoln and the First Shot. Louisiana State UP, 1963.
McPherson, James M. Battle Cry of Freedom: The Civil War Era. Oxford UP, 1988.